|
I have to agree with everything said here. The sorting of the faves list, the lack of notifications of what's new, and the lack of notifications of removals really makes some of the potentially most useful functionality of Curse very hard to use.
The odd thing, like Beutju mentioned, is that all of this (except the removal notifications) used to be there until recently. The favorites page is now the most useless it has ever been in Curse's history.
I'd like to see the ability to sort to page - by the column we pick - come back.
I'd like to see "updated" notifications come back. These used to be "since you last visited that addon page" rather than "since your last login" though. The former makes much more sense to me.
I'd like to see the favorites email and/or RSS notification come back. Yes, that functionality generates a lot of traffic, but that's because it's useful, and because that's the nature of a file repository used by thousands of people.
Notification for deleted projects would be something new, but it would be extremely useful. I definitely agree with the OP on this. The thing is, I recently logged in to Curse again after a few months off, and I *know* there were addons missing from my faves list that ARE still active projects on Curse. So, personally, I still think there's something more going on here than just old projects getting deleted.
I know I'm not going to change any developer minds on this, but I found Curse much easier to navigate and use - both as a user and a mod author - before the Curse.com/CurseForge.com split. Just before the split it was a joy to use, but now... mostly a headache. Performance is better than ever, but figuring out where and how to do anything - and on which of the two sites to do it - is a chore.
Finally, on the "beta" issue, I'm going to comment on this since I just got "bit" by it myself. In my opinion there is no reason for a mod author to *ever* mark an addon as alpha or beta, simply because our users will *never* be notified of its existence. That's pretty counter-productive. The only place alpha/beta mods show up is in the file list on the project page, meaning our users will have to actively seek them out without any prior clue that they're going to find anything new. That's not good. The way it recently struck me is that my latest "release" version was for WoW 2.4. My conversion to 3.0 isn't complete, but I wanted to give my users at least partial functionality now, so I marked my update as "beta". Well, of course Curse still listed my old 2.4 version as "current", even though it is completely useless now. I removed that "beta" tag real quick, so that my users would get SOME indication it was there.
Curse used to mark an addon as updated even if a beta release was posted, which made sense. Users might choose not to download the beta, but at least their favorites pages told them there was something new.
I know this sounds really negative, but that's only because I want Curse to succeed, and become again what it used to be. A few months ago it was great. Now... it does a whole lot less.
|