Hi,

so any good addons to rate and track players?

Like their talents spec, if they are dd, tank or heal. How good they are. Maybe for DDs save the DPS of Recount, etc?

That is a lot of information to store and keep track of. You can try http://www.wowinterface.com/downloads/info8712-Karmaplayertracking.html

well any others? I had karma, was pretty nice but when I use it GuildAds is spamming me with its traffic, the GA author said that is because karma doesn't access the chatframe correctly or something like that :/

Check out DoIKnowYou. It might be close to what your looking for.