I'm having a hard time deciding which to take.  Any suggestions?

I chose amorsmith because that covers most of the slots on your character (e.g. everything your character wears). With weaponsmith you only need to make 1(two-handed weapon) or 2(2 one-handed weapons) items for yourself. That's just my opinion but hope it helps with your decision.

I'm probably going to go Armorsmith, because with weaponsmith, my choice is limited.

Besides, crafting armor is much more easier than farming for honor ><

My Pally went Armorsmithing. The ability to socket armor is handy and dandy!

pick either one, it doesnt matter come 375 and up, since theres no specific items.